I was driving my daughter to her second day of high school when she told me she was getting her PE uniform on Thursday. The flood of blue nostalgia didn’t go unnoticed as I nearly choked myself swallowing one million stories of back in the day.
When I was in high school, I had a PE teacher I’ll call Coach Rogers, who regularly asked me how gay I was on that particular day
“Hey, Crow. How gay are you today?”
The fact of the matter was that I wasn’t gay that day or any other day in particular, so the question itself never really bothered me in the sense that it described anything real. I knew the answer regardless of his inferences.
What pissed me off was being made an example of. Constantly. Publicly. There was a kind of subculture around that sort of thing back then—this casual use of “gay” as a punchline, a status check, a way to knock somebody down a notch. It wasn’t just kids, either. Some staff participated in it too, or at least tolerated it in a way that made it feel like part of the environment.
Sometime during my sophomore year, we were playing a game in PE called crab soccer, which is exactly as dignified as it sounds. You would get down into a crab position and sort of play soccer in the rank-ass wrestling room. Futsal, for idiots. In the gayest room on campus, no less.
At some point during the game, another kid broke my arm. Accident or not, who knows.
Either way, I came back to school with my arm in a full cast and a note from my doctor saying I couldn’t participate in PE and would need to be given something else to do. I was never given an alternative and at the end of the semester, Coach Rogers failed me for non-participation.
Fortunately, that pissed off the right person, my dad. Who showed up at the school and had what I remember as a fairly contentious meeting with Coach Rogers and the vice principal. Eventually, the failing grade was changed to a passing grade. I don’t remember exactly what bureaucratic trick they used. Back then, we were graded A through F. I only remember the F disappearing. What I remember more clearly is my dad. It was one of the rare times I saw him get genuinely angry on my behalf and handle some business that I was completely incapable of handling myself.
But I was also angry, and I was gradually becoming the kind of person who wasn’t going to take things the way people expected me to take them. And it wasn’t just me. A whole group of my friends got pulled into this general culture in different ways. Different teachers, different kids, same basic idea.
By the time we were seniors, some of it had almost flipped on its head. “How gay am I today?” became a kind of running joke among us. “I’m incredibly gay today.” It was sarcasm, but it was also something else. A way of taking the word back just enough to make it useless against us. If you want me to be something in your mind, fine. I’ll be that thing until it stops meaning what you think it means. That shift built up over time, and it came to a head near the end of our senior year during an annual school competition called Air Band.
Air Band was exactly what it sounds like. You got up in front of the whole school and performed lip-synced music routines like it was a concert. It was 50% talent show and 100% a popularity contest. So, a group of mostly unpopular friends and I built a Village People routine. It was choreographed, over the top, and very deliberately leaning into the whole thing.
We pushed it.
Not obscenely, not in a way that crossed any real line, but enough that nobody could pretend we didn’t know exactly what we were doing.
The school wasn’t thrilled.
But the student body was.
We won the competition by popular vote.
Then the school took it away from us. They said the content was objectionable and the prize money disappeared. The official explanation was vague enough to sound administrative rather than personal, but the message was clear: it was fine until it wasn’t. We pushed the envelope; they moved the line.
We were pissed. The student body was pissed too.
Not long after that, I was standing in a hallway near the school office talking to a friend when I heard it from behind me.
“Hey there, faggot. How gay are you today?”
Then I got slapped on the ass.
It was Coach Rogers.
It happened so fast I didn’t even process it at first. He had just walked up behind me and done it like it was nothing, just the ongoing joke he had been running for years. What he didn’t know was that the vice principal was standing nearby.
Pure coincidence.
And to his credit, the vice principal handled it immediately. He saw it. Coach Rogers saw that he saw it. And within seconds the two of them were in the vice principal’s office.
I got pulled out of class shortly after.
Coach Rogers apologized to me directly.
There was a lot of hemming and hawing about “bad judgments” and “misunderstandings,” a lot of promises that “it’ll never happen again,” and all the other language adults use when they suddenly realize the power has shifted.
And then it was over.
I finished high school. I graduated. I moved on.
Mostly.
Years passed.
Then the internet happened.
And like a lot of people from that era, I eventually found myself looking up old names just to see what had become of them. Facebook made it easy. People you assumed had vanished were suddenly just… there. With jobs and families and opinions and carefully curated versions of themselves. At some point I looked up Coach Rogers. He had retired. Apparently, he was well regarded. A beloved coach, according to whatever trace of institutional memory I found online. He had also moved out of state. To the same small city where my parents had moved.
Which was weird.
I don’t remember the exact sequence of events after that. I don’t remember consciously deciding that I needed to know where Coach Rogers lived. But somehow, I ended up with his address. That sentence probably deserves a little more examination than I’m willing to give it. I had Coach Rogers’ home address. And the next time I was visiting my parents, I drove past his house. I had no plan. This is important, although I realize that people with no plans generally don’t look up addresses and then drive to them. But I really didn’t. I wasn’t going there to confront him. I wasn’t going to demand an apology I’d already received. I wasn’t going to kick his ass. I wasn’t going to throw a brick through a window or spray-paint HOW GAY ARE YOU TODAY? across his garage door.
At least I don’t think I was.
I just drove by.
There it was.
A house.
Coach Rogers lived in a house.
This was information I apparently needed.
I slowed down enough to look at it and then kept driving. 1I didn’t stop. I didn’t knock. I didn’t see him. And I have wondered occasionally what I would have done if I had. Probably nothing. Maybe something. I honestly have no idea. Maybe I wanted him to see me. Maybe I wanted to see him. Maybe I wanted to discover that he had become a tiny old man watering a hydrangea. Maybe fifteen-year-old me had been sitting quietly in the passenger seat all those years and just wanted to know where the motherfucker lived.
Whatever the reason, we found him. And then we drove away.
He’s dead now, I believe. Which puts a fairly definitive end to whatever confrontation I apparently wasn’t planning. And now, decades later, I’m driving my own daughter to her second day of high school and she tells me she’s getting her PE uniform on Thursday. A completely ordinary sentence from a kid starting high school in a school that is not mine, in a world that isn’t necessarily better—it’s just different.
In any case, it turns out enough time will give you enough space for the phrase “PE uniform” to summon a dead man I haven’t seen in decades into the car with us. My daughter in the passenger seat and Coach Rogers in the back, dying to know exactly how gay I am today.
And, well, it depends.